Some cookies get eaten in two bites. Others get photographed, passed around the table and admired before anybody dares to take a bite. Brim and Butter makes the second kind.

The small Baton Rouge cookie business belongs to Lydia, who describes a double life on her website. By day she works in data, where precision matters. By night she trades numbers for flour, and that same attention to structure shows up in every piped line of icing.

Cookies by the batch

Everything here is a hand-decorated sugar cookie, and the menu is built around batches rather than single treats.

The Seasonal Batch is the baker's choice. Lydia curates a limited-time set inspired by the calendar, whether that means spooky Halloween designs, festive Christmas cookies or even a crawfish season collection. Depending on the season, a batch might be two dozen minis or one dozen signature-size cookies. Local pickup is $45, and a shipped version within Louisiana is $60. Pickup windows are announced each season, so join the mailing list to catch the holiday drop.

Custom sets for your party

Planning an office party, a baby shower or a holiday open house? Custom batches start at $52 per dozen for signature cookies measuring 3 to 4 inches. Lydia designs each set, prints custom cutters when needed, and invoices a 60% deposit to hold your spot on the calendar. If her schedule allows, rush orders run an extra $10 per dozen. You can also add Nibbles, little coordinating minis that stretch a set further.

A gift that keeps arriving

For the person who has everything, consider a Batch Box subscription. The Signature box brings a dozen full-size cookies for $65, and the Mini box brings two dozen minis for $60, both shipped within Louisiana with shipping included. Subscribe monthly and save 10%.

One heads-up: the kitchen is not allergen-free, and nuts and dairy are present.

Order at brimandbutter.shop, and maybe hide a cookie or two before the guests arrive.

Photo courtesy of Brim and Butter.

DigBR Staff

What used to be a monthly print magazine now turned ‘DIG’ital. DIG is how Baton Rouge keeps the pulse of our great city. We curate what’s important and deliver it fast throughout the day here and on our social channels.

Learn More

By DigBR Staff

November 19, 2026

Follow Along for updates

@DIGBATONROUGE